Part two of our Set card game review

Set card game review, part two

Click here to read part one of this review

The gameplay

To not quite borrow a quote from Ghostbusters: there is no strategy in Set... only mental muscle. Once you learn how to play, playing again and again just makes you faster and more accurate.

These are great qualities of course (among other uses, Set has been integrated as a tool for teachers, particularly in math classes).

The straightforward deck and game mechanic lend themselves to a variety of variations. The company's website lists six, including poker-esque versions and alternate ways of scoring. There is also an option for younger children and anyone wanting a quick introduction. Start with just the solid symbol cards. Sets now only have to meet three criteria, making this an excellent warmup if you haven't played frequently or recently.

A Set deck, therefore, can be at least seven games, a teaching tool and a math puzzle. If you choose to just use it as directed, you'll find yourself playing a game in the more classic sense, finding enjoyment in a straightforward but intriguing test of your eyes and brain.

Yes, you're competing with everyone at the table for the final score; but really, you're competing with yourself. Hey, who cued up the 'The More You Know...' soundtrack?

Pros and cons

The learning curve on the SET Card Game isn't too steep (it's rare for even a rank beginner to go through multiple hands without capturing a set or two) but experience seems to count for quite a bit. As a result, people who have played for a while and are 'in the mindset' can often tear past newer players, calling 'Set!' while others are still scanning each card.

This has the potential to alienate new players, but can be mitigated by doing what most (especially older) Set players seem to do: not take the game too seriously. Competing at Set is kind of like competing over a jigsaw puzzle. Sure you can trash talk and race each other, but if there are hard feelings when it's all over you've probably done something wrong.

Set's biggest downsides are its potential to frustrate and its complete lack of strategic depth. Frustration is more likely with younger children, so parents will probably want to introduce them to the game more slowly.

On the other negative, Set's straightforwardness can make it seem too much like a child's game to some, albeit a tough one.

Set has three big things going for it: It's fast to learn and set up, so it can be played any time, anywhere. With multiple gameplay options and its utility as a classroom tool, it can go a lot further than it initially seems. And it's unlike any other card game on the market. While gameplay is fairly repetitive, its particular mental demands keep it from becoming dull or rote.

The verdict

The SET Card Game is an excellent game for families with preteens and younger children, and it definitely holds its own with peer groups of all ages. Just hearing it described probably won't tell you whether or not you'll like playing the game, so find a friend or a party where its being played and sit in on a few hands. Then pick up a copy to feed you and/or your family's new addiction.